Enjoy NY-style pizza in the heart of Sanford

From our family to yours, Goodfellas serves up delicious pizza and Italian dishes using only the highest quality products and freshest ingredients. 

pepperoni pizza
grid
grid
grid
pizza station
sal making pizza

Ciao!

Goodfellas pizzeria of Sanford isn’t just any ordinary establishment; it’s a family owned small business that has poured their heart and soul into creating an unforgettable dining experience for all.

From traditional hand-tossed pizzas to mouthwatering pasta dishes cooked to perfection, Goodfella’s promises to be a haven for all Italian cuisine enthusiasts.

But it’s not just about the food; it’s about the love and passion that Sal & his family bring to the table. They are dedicated to providing exceptional service and creating a welcoming atmosphere for families and friends.

Buon Appetito!

– The Ciaccio Family

grid

Check out our lunch specials

Available from 11am-3pm daily

gluten free white pizza with artichoke
grid

Law enforcement get 10% off every order

Must show proof. Thank you for your service!

grid
lemons
Stromboli with sauce
cheese pull pepperoni pizza
chopped salad